“The house-backed sports book model is a carnival game… designed for someone that’s able to suspend disbelief, maybe convince themselves they can win, but it is not in any way designed or built for sharp, sort of advantage, smart users at all.” ~ Alex Kane
Sponsor’s Message: Promoting a sustainable, entertainment-first global gaming industry.
Play’n GO is celebrating its 20th anniversary in 2025. Drawing on that experience from the dawn of the iGaming industry through to today, Play’n GO designs and creates world-class slot games in the online casino space.
Play’n GO wants to see a sustainable industry that puts players first. To realize that vision, Play’n GO:
Creates games designed to be entertaining and fun first
Actively lobbies for increased regulation to keep players safe
Refuses to make games that feature mechanics that we believe to be predatory, such as those that allow players to pay hundreds of times their normal stake to buy into the bonus round directly (‘Bonus Buy’ games)
Now live in over 35 regulated territories around the world, including all US and Canadian iGaming jurisdictions, Play’n GO is the leading provider of entertainment to the online casino industry.
For more info, visit www.playngo.com
In his record-tying fourth appearance (matched only by Kim Lund), Sporttrade CEO and Founder Alex Kane breaks down the fundamental economic model of modern US sports betting using a memorable carnival analogy.
Traditional sportsbooks, he argues, are deliberately built like carnival games: designed for entertainment, not to reward skill.
Kane argues that burdensome taxes and licensing fees, coupled with heavy-handed regulation have forced operators into a high-margin “house-backed” model that can only survive by attracting casual “happy losers” (a term stolen from Alun Bowden) while systematically limiting or banning sharp players. Like a parent taking their kid to the carnival, they know they are going to spend $100 on cheap fried foods and to win a $10 stuffed animal… but their kid will go home happy, so money well spent. And more importantly, they will drop another $100 when the carnival comes back to town next year.
The conversation kicks off with Massachusetts’ new rule requiring sportsbooks to tell limited customers why they were restricted, a policy Kane calls well-intentioned but ultimately superficial, as most operators responded with boilerplate excuses. He contends regulators still don’t fully grasp the license they (state lawmakers) granted: permission to offer any odds, any bonus, and to remove any winner.
Without structural change, there is literally nowhere for skilled bettors to go.
Kane contrasts this carnival model with CFTC-regulated prediction markets and exchanges like Sporttrade. In the exchange world there is no single house counterparty, no ability to limit winners, and no room for injury insurance, parlay boosts, or risk-free bets that “trick” customers into worse pricing. The result is purer, more transparent speculation—but also fewer flashy promos that casual players have been conditioned to expect.
We also talk at length about consumer spending behaviors, whether at sportsbooks or the grocery store, as well as:
Why DraftKings, FanDuel, and others have perfected the “happy loser” ecosystem, and why there isn’t anything wrong with that.
Lessons from online poker: losing players sustain the game; once they leave, the ecosystem collapses.
A direct message to state regulators from Kane: allowing sportsbooks to also offer prediction markets would actually increase tax revenue while serving both recreational and sharp customers.
This is a really strong episode for anyone looking to get the prediction market perspective on the debate, as well as some of the best arguments I’ve heard for cats and dogs sportsbooks and prediction markets peacefully coexisting.
STTP Note: Sporttrade has applied for a DCM license from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
Follow Alex Kane on X
Listen to Alex Kane’s previous podcast appearances:
An open letter to US Sports Betting Legislators and Regulators published on Straight to the Point in March 2025 from Kane:
